Sexual Crimes in Conflict Database
A collection of relevant literature and case law
Showing 11 to 13 of 13 results.
-
Jurisprudence judicial mechanism
ICTR - Innocent Sagahutu (Ndindiliyimana et al. “Military II”)
- Issues
- Definitions/Elements of Sexual Violence Crimes
- Country
- Rwanda
- Keywords
- Acquittal Command Responsibility Humiliating and Degrading Treatment War Crimes Rape as Crime Against Humanity
- Reference link
- http://unictr.unmict.org/en/cases/ictr-00-56
- Type of mechanism
- International Criminal Tribunal/Court
- Name of mechanism
- International Criminal Tribunal for Rwanda (ICTR)
- Name of accused
- Innocent Sagahutu
- Charges
- Rape as a crime against humanity and rape, humiliating and degrading treatment as a violation of Article 3 common to the Geneva Conventions and of Additional Protocol II as war crimes under Article 6(3) (command responsibility) for failing to prevent or to punish the rapes committed by soldiers from the A squad of the Reconnaissance battalion, led by Sagahutu and under the command of Major Nzuwonemeye in the kiosks at the entrance of the hospital of Kigali during April, May and June 1994.
- Trial chamber verdict
- Sagahutu was found not guilty by the Trial Chamber (on 17 May 2011)for the sexual violence charges.
- sentencing
- Sagahutu was sentenced to 15 years’ imprisonment on 11 February 2014 by the Appeals Chamber (for other charges).
- Appeals chamber verdict
- The Prosecution did not appeal the acquittals for sexual violence.
- Status
- 2715
- Case number
- ICTR-00-56
-
Jurisprudence non-judicial mechanisms
International Commission of Inquiry on Guinea
- Country
- Guinea
- Keywords
- Rape Humiliating and Degrading Treatment Forced Nudity Sexual Slavery Killings
- Reference link
- www.legal-tools.org/en/browse/record/c5939f/
- Research focus
- Causality, Functionality and Logic of Conflict-related Sexual Violence
- Type of mechanism
- Commission of Inquiry
- Name of mechanism
- International Commission of Inquiry on Guinea
- Status
- 2715
- Findings
- On 28 September 2009, the red berets and gendarmes surrounded the stadium, blocked the exits, stormed through the main gates, fired tear gas and set about killing or wounding the demonstrators or subjecting them to sexual assault. In under two hours, hundreds of civilians had died or been seriously wounded, stripped in public and subjected to widespread sexual abuse, being unable to flee as the exits from the stadium had been blocked. The authorities then began an organized attempt to cover up the crimes and, as a result, at least 89 persons have been reported missing, some are suffering from permanent injuries, while others will be afflicted with long-term physical and mental suffering. Among the many crimes the COI confirmed (e.g. killings), it also confirmed that at least 109 women were subjected to (gang) rape and other sexual violence, including sexual mutilation and sexual slavery. Several women died of their wounds following particularly cruel sexual attacks. Women were subjected to collective rape, often involving the use of objects, in public places, and all these acts were committed over a period of less than two hours, mainly in one place, in full view and with the full knowledge of all those who were present.
- Recommendations
- On 18 December 2009, the COI recommended, <i>inter alia</i>, that the Guinean Government should be strongly urged to provide the families concerned with all relevant information on the case of persons who have disappeared, that the International Criminal Court should be asked to investigate the persons alleged to have committed crimes against humanity, that adequate reparation should be made to the victims and that targeted sanctions should be imposed against the principal perpetrators of the violations. <b>The COI qualified the acts committed as: (1) violations of human rights and (2) violations of international criminal law.</b> As for the violations of human rights it held that the sexual slavery to which a number of women were subjected constitutes, <i>inter alia</i>, a <i>violation of the prohibition against holding anyone in slavery or servitude </i>(Article 8 of the ICCPR). The at least 109 women who were found subjected to sexual violence were held to be grave violations of the Convention against Torture and Other Cruel, Inhuman or Degrading Treatment or Punishment, i.e. <i>torture</i> (Article 1). These acts inflicted “severe pain or suffering” in order to punish the victims for an act which they had committed (participation in a demonstration prohibited by the Government) and to intimidate them, particularly to deter them from demonstrating against the authorities in the future. The persons responsible for these acts were soldiers, gendarmes, policemen and militiamen. The latter clearly acted “at the instigation of [a public official] or with the consent or acquiescence [of a public official]” since they were operating in conjunction with the security forces which were engaged in repression. Some of these acts, such as stripping women naked in public or certain less severe types of aggression, may be categorized as <i>cruel, inhuman or degrading treatment</i>, the COI stated. These acts of sexual violence were also considered <i>violations of the Convention on the Elimination of All Forms of Discrimination against Women</i>, since they were clearly directed against women as such. As for the violations of international criminal law, the COI held that it was established that <i>crimes against humanity</i> had been committed, <i>including rape, sexual slavery and sexual violence</i>. The COI referred to the Rome Statute for the prohibition of rape and other forms of sexual violence as a crime against humanity (Article 7(1)(g)).
- Date of report / release
- 1909-12-18
- Reparations / awards
- <p style="text-align:justify; line-height:115%"><span lang="EN-US">As for the reparations, specific mention was made of the victims of sexual violence. It was held that victims should receive, e.g.: </span></p> <p style="text-align:justify; line-height:115%"><span lang="EN-US">(1) medical treatment and adequate care, in particular for the victims of sexual violence, who should be given treatment for HIV/AIDS and other sexually transmitted diseases; and </span></p> <p style="text-align:justify; line-height:115%"><span lang="EN-US">(2) psychological counselling, particularly for victims of gender-based violence, especially rape and sexual violence.</span></p>
-
Jurisprudence non-judicial mechanisms
South African Truth and Reconciliation Commission
- Country
- South Africa
- Keywords
- Rape Threat of Rape Sexual Abuse Humiliating and Degrading Treatment
- Research focus
- Inequality and Discrimination against Women during Armed Conflict
- Type of mechanism
- Truth Commission
- Name of mechanism
- South African Truth and Reconciliation Commission
- Status
- 2715
- Findings
- There, the TRC concludes that the state was responsible for the severe ill treatment of women in custody through harassment and the deliberate withholding of medical attention, food, and water. Women were abused by the security forces in ways that specifically exploited their vulnerabilities as women, such as rape or threats of rape and other forms of sexual abuse, threats against family and children, removal of children from their care, false stories about illness or death of family members and children, and humiliation and abuse surrounding biological functions such as menstruation and childbirth.
- Recommendations
- Among their recommendations and proposals of reconciliation, the TRC stressed the importance of being sensitive to the needs of groups that have been particularly disadvantaged in the past, notably women and children. The recommendations of the final report related to specific areas in the public and private sectors that the TRC believed could assist in the consolidation of democracy, the building of a culture of human rights, and the reconciliation process. The TRC recommended, for example, that government should pay more attention to the transformation of education, the provision of shelter, access to clean water and health services, and the creation of job opportunities. It will be impossible to create a meaningful human rights culture, the TRC argued, without high priority to economic justice. Moreover, the TRC urged that human rights curricula be introduced in formal education, specialized education, and the training of law enforcement personnel. Issues such as racism, gender discrimination, conflict resolution, and the rights of children should be included in such curricula. Concerning the administration of justice, the TRC recommended training in human rights principles and issues, including gender-specific abuse and appropriate responses. It also urged that imbalances in the racial and gender composition of judges on the high court be urgently addressed and that a fast-track judicial training program be introduced for black and female advocates, attorneys, and academics who aspired to judicial appointment. The TRC also suggested that the media intensify programs of affirmative action and empowerment of women to ensure better gender balance.
- Date of report / release
- 2098-10-28
This is free software. Created with LinkAhead
and Django. Licenced under AGPL version 3.0 (Sources).