Sexual Crimes in Conflict Database

A collection of relevant literature and case law

Showing 51 to 60 of 67 results.

  • Jurisprudence judicial mechanism

    ICTY - Radoslav Brdanin

    Year
    2007
    Issues
    Definitions/Elements of Sexual Violence Crimes
    Country
    Former Yugoslavia
    Keywords
    Acquittal Persecution on Sexual Grounds Kunarac Stakic Specific Intent

    Reference link
    http://www.icty.org/cases/party/673/4
    Type of mechanism
    International Criminal Tribunal/Court
    Name of mechanism
    International Criminal Tribunal for Former Yugoslavia (ICTY)
    Name of accused
    Radoslav Brdanin
    Charges
    Brdanin was charged with: - Persecution as a crime against humanity under Article 7(1) (aiding and abetting) for rapes and sexual assaults of Bosnian Muslim women in the Keraterm camp in July 1992, in the Trnopolje camp in July 1992 and the Omarska camp in June 1992 (the sexual violence was incorporated under torture as persecution). - Torture as a grave breach of the Geneva Conventions of 1949 as a war crime under Article 7(1) (aiding and abetting), which included rapes of Bosnian Muslim women in the Keraterm camp in July 1992, in the Trnopolje camp in July 1992 and the Omarska camp in June 1992. - Causing serious bodily or mental harm as genocide or, alternatively, complicity in genocide under Articles 7(1) and 7(3), which included rapes and sexual assault of Bosnian Muslim and Bosnian Croat detainees in various camps and detention facilities.
    Trial chamber verdict
    Brdanin was found guilty on 1 September 2004 of: - Persecution as a crime against humanity under Article 7(1) (aiding and abetting); - Torture as a grave breach of the Geneva Conventions of 1949 as a war crime under Article 7(1) (aiding and abetting). Brdanin was found not guilty of: - Causing serious bodily or mental harm as genocide or, alternatively, complicity in genocide under Articles 7(1) and 7(3). He was found not guilty for genocide since the specific intent for genocide could not be established.
    sentencing
    Brdanin was sentenced by the Appeals Chamber to 30 years’ imprisonment on 3 April 2007 (for other charges).
    Appeals chamber verdict
    On 3 April 2007, the Appeals Chamber reversed the convictions for sexual violence – i.e. persecution as a crime against humanity and torture as a grave breach of the Geneva Conventions of 1949 as a war crime – as it could not be established that Brdanin’s conduct constituted either encouragement or moral support to the camp personnel (aiding and abetting) that had a substantial effect on the commission of torture.
    Status
    2715
    Case number
    IT-99-36

  • Jurisprudence judicial mechanism

    ICTY - Ramush Haradinaj ("Haradinaj et al.")

    Year
    2012
    Issues
    Definitions/Elements of Sexual Violence Crimes Evidentiary Rules Regarding Sexual Violence Prosecutions
    Country
    Former Yugoslavia
    Keywords
    Acquittal Aiding and Abetting Forced Nudity Genitalia Kunarac Unreliable Testimony Retrial

    Reference link
    http://www.icty.org/cases/party/698/4
    Type of mechanism
    International Criminal Tribunal/Court
    Name of mechanism
    International Criminal Tribunal for Former Yugoslavia (ICTY)
    Name of accused
    Ramush Haradinaj
    Charges
    Haradinaj was charged with: - Persecution as a crime against humanity or, in the alternative, torture and other inhumane acts as crimes against humanity and cruel treatment, torture and outrages upon personal dignity as violations of the laws or customs of war as a war crime under Article 7(1) (JCE or, in the alternative, ordering, instigating or aiding and abetting), which included the stripping of Witness SST7/38 naked and the sexual assault of Witness SST7/38’s sister. - Persecution as a crime against humanity or, in the alternative, torture and other inhumane acts (serious physical and mental injury) as crimes against humanity and cruel treatment and torture as violations of the laws or customs of war as a war crime under Article 7(1) (JCE or, in the alternative, ordering, instigating or aiding and abetting), which included kicking Naser Lika in the testicles while he lay on the ground. - Persecution as a crime against humanity or, in the alternative, torture, rape and other inhumane acts (serious physical and mental injury) as crimes against humanity, rape as a violation of the laws or customs of war as a war crime and cruel treatment and torture as violations of the laws or customs of war as a war crime under Article 7(1) (JCE), which included the repeated rape of Witness SST7/02.
    Trial chamber verdict
    Although Haradinaj was charged with sexual violence crimes, he was acquitted on all charges against him by the Trial Chamber on 3 April 2008, thus all of the sexual violence charges stipulated above.
    Appeals chamber verdict
    The Appeals Chamber on 19 July 2010 quashed the Trial Chamber’s decision to acquit Haradinaj on several charges, including the charge of cruel treatment and torture as violations of the laws or customs of war as a war crime under Article 7(1) (JCE or, in the alternative, ordering, instigating or aiding and abetting), which included kicking Naser Lika in the testicles while he lay on the ground, and ordered that Haradinaj be retried on this charge. The Appeals Chamber confirmed the acquittals for the other sexual violence charges. Haradinaj was acquitted by the Trial Chamber on 29 November 2012 after retrial.
    Status
    2715
    Case number
    IT-04-84

  • Jurisprudence judicial mechanism

    ICTY - Rasim Delic

    Year
    2008
    Issues
    Evidentiary Rules Regarding Sexual Violence Prosecutions
    Country
    Former Yugoslavia
    Keywords
    Acquittal Unclear Indictment Detention Centers

    Reference link
    http://www.icty.org/cases/party/679/4
    Type of mechanism
    International Criminal Tribunal/Court
    Name of mechanism
    International Criminal Tribunal for Former Yugoslavia (ICTY)
    Name of accused
    Rasim Delic
    Charges
    Delic was charged with: - Cruel treatment as a violation of the laws or customs of war as a war crime under Article 7(3) (command responsibility) for the sexual assault of Witnesses DRW-1, DRW-2 and DRW-3, detained at the Kamenica camp. - Rape as a violation of the laws or customs of war as a war crime for the same crimes as above.
    Trial chamber verdict
    Delic was found not guilty by the Trial Chamber on 15 September 2008 of: - Cruel treatment as a violation of the laws or customs of war as a war crime under Article 7(3) (command responsibility) for the sexual assault of Witnesses DRW-1, DRW-2 and DRW-3, detained at the Kamenica camp. The Trial Chamber held that these victims were subjected to sexual violence at the Vatrostalna facility, but not at the Kamenica camp, as was pleaded in the indictment. - Rape as a violation of the laws or customs of war as a war crime for the same crimes as above. However, for this charge Delic was already acquitted during trial on 26 February 2008. Both the Prosecution and Defense agreed to this and the Prosecution has even asked earlier on in the proceedings for a withdrawal of the charge.
    sentencing
    Delic was therefore sentenced by the Trial Chamber to 3 years’ imprisonment on 15 September 2008 (for other charges).
    Appeals chamber verdict
    During the appellate proceedings, on 16 April 2010, Delic died while on provisional release. On 29 June 2010, the Appeals Chamber terminated the appellate proceedings and ruled that Trial Chamber Judgement to be final.
    Status
    2715
    Case number
    IT-04-83

  • Jurisprudence judicial mechanism

    ICTY - Slobodan Praljak ("Prlic et al.")

    Year
    2017
    Issues
    Modes of Liability Definitions/Elements of Sexual Violence Crimes Evidentiary Rules Regarding Sexual Violence Prosecutions
    Country
    Former Yugoslavia
    Keywords
    Acquittal Extended Joint Criminal Enterprise Foreseeable Consequence

    Reference link
    http://www.icty.org/cases/party/766/4
    Type of mechanism
    International Criminal Tribunal/Court
    Name of mechanism
    International Criminal Tribunal for Former Yugoslavia (ICTY)
    Name of accused
    Slobodan Praljak
    Charges
    Praljak was charged with: - Persecution as a crime against humanity under Article 7(1) (JCE III); - Rape as a crime against humanity and inhuman treatment (sexual assault) as a grave breach of the Geneva Conventions of 1949 as a war crime under Article 7(1) (JCE) and 7(3) (command responsibility).
    Trial chamber verdict
    Praljak was found not guilty by the Trial Chamber on 29 May 2013 for both of the sexual violence charges stipulated above. The Trial Chamber could not find beyond reasonable doubt that Praljak could have foreseen that members of the HVO would commit sexual abuse in the town of Vares and in Stupni Do from 23 to 25 October 1993. Judge Antonetti dissenting on the not guilty verdict for rape as a crime against humanity and a war crime.
    sentencing
    Praljak was sentenced by the Trial Chamber to 20 years’ imprisonment on 29 May 2013 (for other charges). This sentence was reaffirmed by the Appeals Chamber on 29th November 2017.
    Appeals chamber verdict
    On 29th November 2017, the Appeals Chamber in its judgment granted Praljak’s appeal in part, although it affirmed the sentence of 20 years of imprisonment against him.
    Status
    2778
    Case number
    IT-04-74

  • Jurisprudence judicial mechanism

    ICTY - Stojan Župljanin (“Stanišic & Župljanin”)

    Year
    2016
    Issues
    Sexual Violence as a Weapon of War
    Country
    Former Yugoslavia
    Keywords
    Camp Detention Centers Rape/Sexual Violence in Detention Bosnian Muslim Population Acquittal Joint Criminal Enterprise (JCE)

    Reference link
    http://www.icty.org/cases/party/783/4
    Type of mechanism
    International Criminal Tribunal/Court
    Name of mechanism
    International Criminal Tribunal for Former Yugoslavia (ICTY)
    Name of accused
    Stojan Župljanin
    Charges
    - Persecution as a crime against humanity under Article 7(1) of Bosnian Muslim and Bosnian Croat populations, which included sexual violence committed in detention facilities.- Torture as a violation of the laws or customs of war as a war crime under Article 7(1) for subjecting Bosnian Muslims and Bosnian Croats in camps, police stations, military barracks and other detention facilities to various crimes, including sexual violence.- Torture as a crime against humanity, cruel treatment as a violation of the laws or customs of war as a war crime and inhumane acts as a crime against humanity under Article 7(1) for subjecting Bosnian Muslims and Bosnian Croats in camps, police stations, military barracks and other detention facilities to various crimes, including sexual violence (similar as above under ‘torture’).
    Trial chamber verdict
    Župljain was found guilty by the Trial Chamber on 27 March 2013 of: - Persecution as a crime against humanity - Torture as a violation of the laws or customs of war as a war crime Župljain was found not guilty of (in light of the cumulative convictions principles): - Torture as a crime against humanity, cruel treatment as a violation of the laws or customs of war as a war crime and inhumane acts as a crime against humanity (similar as above under ‘torture’).
    sentencing
    Župljain was sentenced to 22 years’ imprisonment on 30 June 2016.
    Appeals chamber verdict
    The Appeals Chamber confirmed the Trial Chamber's judgment on 30 June 2016.
    Status
    2715
    Case number
    IT-08-91

  • Jurisprudence judicial mechanism

    ICTY - Tihomir Blaskic

    Year
    2004
    Issues
    Modes of Liability
    Country
    Former Yugoslavia
    Keywords
    Acquittal Command Responsibility Effective Control Cumulative Conviction

    Reference link
    http://www.icty.org/cases/party/667/4
    Type of mechanism
    International Criminal Tribunal/Court
    Name of mechanism
    International Criminal Tribunal for Former Yugoslavia (ICTY)
    Name of accused
    Tihomir Blaskic
    Charges
    Inhuman treatment as a grave breach of the Geneva Conventions of 1949 as a war crime and cruel treatment as a violation of the laws or customs of war as a war crime under Article 7(3) (command responsibility), which included rapes of Bosnian Muslims detained by the HVO in Rotilj village (Kiseljak municipality) and in Dubravica primary school (Vitez municipality) and committed by the HVO soldiers and Military Police.
    Trial chamber verdict
    Blaskic was found guilty by the Trial Chamber on 3 March 2000 for the sexual violence charges.
    sentencing
    Blaskic was sentenced to 9 years’ imprisonment on 29 July 2004 (for other charges).
    Appeals chamber verdict
    The Appeals Chamber on 29 July 2004 dismissed both convictions as the cruel treatment as a violation of the laws or customs of war as a war crime conviction was considered to be an impermissible cumulative conviction, while the inhuman treatment as a grave breach of the Geneva Conventions of 1949 as a war crime could not be sustained since Blaskic was held not have exercised effective control over his subordinates responsible for the rapes.
    Status
    2715
    Case number
    IT-95-14

  • Jurisprudence judicial mechanism

    ICTY - Veselin Sljivancanin ("Mrksic et al.")

    Year
    2010
    Issues
    Evidentiary Rules Regarding Sexual Violence Prosecutions
    Country
    Former Yugoslavia
    Keywords
    Acquittal

    Reference link
    http://www.icty.org/cases/party/748/4
    Type of mechanism
    International Criminal Tribunal/Court
    Name of mechanism
    International Criminal Tribunal for Former Yugoslavia (ICTY)
    Name of accused
    Veselin Sljivancanin (“Mrksic et al.”)
    Charges
    Sljivancanin was charged with: - Persecution as a crime against humanity under Article 7(1) (JCE) and 7(3) (command responsibility), which included sexual assault of Croats and other non-Serbs who were in the Vukovar hospital after the fall of Vukovar. - Torture as a crime against humanity, inhumane acts as a crime against humanity, torture as a violation of the laws or customs of war as a war crime and cruel treatment as a violation of the laws or customs of war as a war crime under Article 7(1) (JCE) and 7(3) (command responsibility), which included sexual assault of a female detainee at the Ovcara farm.
    Trial chamber verdict
    Sljivancanin was found not guilty by the Trial Chamber (on 27 September 2007) of: - Persecution as a crime against humanity under Article 7(1) (JCE) and 7(3) (command responsibility); - Torture as a crime against humanity, inhumane acts as a crime against humanity, torture as a violation of the laws or customs of war as a war crime and cruel treatment as a violation of the laws or customs of war as a war crime under Article 7(1) (JCE) and 7(3) (command responsibility). The Trial Chamber found that there was no evidence of sexual assault.
    sentencing
    Sljivancanin was sentenced by the Appeals Chamber to 10 years’ imprisonment on 8 December 2010.
    Appeals chamber verdict
    The issue was not discussed before the Appeals Chamber.
    Status
    2715
    Case number
    IT-95-13/1

  • Jurisprudence judicial mechanism

    ICTY - Vladimir Lazarevic ("Sainovic et al.; previously Milutinovic et al.")

    Year
    2014
    Issues
    Modes of Liability Definitions/Elements of Sexual Violence Crimes
    Country
    Former Yugoslavia
    Keywords
    Acquittal Aiding and Abetting Definition of Sexual Assault Extended Joint Criminal Enterprise Foreseeable Consequence Knowledge of the Crimes Kunarac Specific Intent

    Reference link
    http://www.icty.org/cases/party/740/4
    Type of mechanism
    International Criminal Tribunal/Court
    Name of mechanism
    International Criminal Tribunal for Former Yugoslavia (ICTY)
    Name of accused
    Vladimir Lazarevic
    Charges
    Lazarevic was charged with: - Deportation as a crime against humanity and other inhumane acts (forcible transfer) as crimes against humanity under Article 7(1) for deliberately creating an atmosphere of fear and oppression through, inter alia, sexual assault of Kosovo Albanian women, in order to forcibly displace and deport Kosovo Albanian civilians; and - Persecution as a crime against humanity under Article 7(1) and 7(3), which included sexual assaults by forces of the Federal Republic of Yugoslavia and Serbia of the Kosovo Albanian population.
    Trial chamber verdict
    Lazarevic was found not guilty by the Trial Chamber on 26 February 2009 of both the above stipulated charges. With regard to deportation as a crime against humanity and other inhumane acts (forcible transfer) as crimes against humanity, the Trial Chamber found that, while the forcible displacements were part of the VJ and MUP organized campaign, it was not satisfied beyond reasonable doubt that sexual assaults were intended aims of this campaign. The Trial Chamber found that it was not proved that Lazarevic was aware that the VJ and MUP were going into some specific crime sites in order to commit sexual assaults and, therefore, the Trial Chamber found that the mental element of aiding and abetting was not established in relation to these crimes. Moreover, it did not find that information regarding the specific sexual assaults, for which it was provided that the VJ was responsible, was available to Lazarevic or that he had reason to know about them.
    sentencing
    Lazarevic was sentenced by the Appeals Chamber to 14 years’ imprisonment on 23 January 2014 (for other charges).
    Status
    2715
    Case number
    IT-05-87

  • Jurisprudence judicial mechanism

    ICTY - Zejnil Delalic (Mucic et al. "Celebici Camp")

    Year
    2001
    Issues
    Modes of Liability Evidentiary Rules Regarding Sexual Violence Prosecutions
    Country
    Former Yugoslavia
    Keywords
    Acquittal Command Responsibility Prior Sexual Conduct Akayesu

    Reference link
    http://www.icty.org/cases/party/676/4
    Type of mechanism
    International Criminal Tribunal/Court
    Name of mechanism
    International Criminal Tribunal for Former Yugoslavia (ICTY)
    Name of accused
    Zejnil Delalic
    Charges
    Delalic was charged with sexual violence as war crimes under Article 7(3) (command responsibility) – see the case of Zdravko Mucic for the crimes he was charged with as well (and even more).
    Trial chamber verdict
    Delalic was acquitted by the Trial Chamber of all charges on 16 November 1998, thus the sexual violence charges included, because it was not established that he had superior responsibility over Celebici prison-camp, its commander, deputy commander or guards.
    Appeals chamber verdict
    Delalic’s acquittal on all charges was affirmed by the Appeals Chamber on 20 February 2001.
    Status
    2715
    Case number
    IT-96-21

  • Jurisprudence judicial mechanism

    ICTY - Zoran Zigic (“Kvocka et al.”)

    Year
    2005
    Issues
    Definitions/Elements of Sexual Violence Crimes Modes of Liability Achievements and Challenges of Sexual Violence Prosecution
    Country
    Former Yugoslavia
    Keywords
    Acquittal Akayesu Cumulative Conviction Extended Joint Criminal Enterprise Foreseeable Consequence Forced Nudity Forced to watch Rape Mental Harm Persecution on Sexual Grounds Kunarac

    Reference link
    http://www.icty.org/cases/party/722/4
    Type of mechanism
    International Criminal Tribunal/Court
    Name of mechanism
    International Criminal Tribunal for Former Yugoslavia (ICTY)
    Name of accused
    Zoran Zigic (“Kvocka et al.”)
    Charges
    - Persecution as a crime against humanity under Article 7(1) (JCE) for sexual assault and rape of Bosnian Muslims, Bosnian Croats and other non-Serbs detained in Omarska camp. - Inhumane acts as crimes against humanity and outrages upon personal dignity as a violation of the laws or customs of war as a war crime for sexual assault and rape of Bosnian Muslims, Bosnian Croats and other non-Serbs detained in Omarska camp.
    Trial chamber verdict
    Zigic was found guilty by the Trial Chamber on 2 November 2001 of: - Persecution as a crime against humanity under Article 7(1) (JCE). Zigic was found not guilty by the Trial Chamber of: - Inhumane acts as crimes against humanity and outrages upon personal dignity as a violation of the laws or customs of war as a war crime.
    sentencing
    Zigic was sentenced by the Appeals Chamber to 25 years’ imprisonment on 28 February 2005 (for other charges).
    Appeals chamber verdict
    Although Zigic was initially found guilty by the Trial Chamber of persecution as a crime against humanity for the sexual violence crimes, this conviction was reversed by the Appeals Chamber on 28 February 2005.
    Status
    2715
    Case number
    IT-98-30/1

This is free software. Created with LinkAhead and Django. Licenced under AGPL version 3.0 (Sources).